Edinburgh does romantic evenings well. The city's natural advantages, a skyline that looks different from every angle, narrow closes lit by old-fashioned lamps, centuries of stone stacked on stone, do a lot of the heavy lifting. But the restaurants and bars have caught up too. The last few years have brought a wave of intimate, chef-driven restaurants with limited seating and seasonal Scottish menus that make big cities' Michelin establishments feel sterile by comparison. The cocktail bar scene, covered in detail in our best bars guide, has enough candlelit basements and hidden doorways to fill a month of date nights.
This list splits roughly into three categories: restaurants worth dressing up for, bars where the lighting does the work, and a couple of experiences (gin distillery, whisky tasting) that give you something to do together beyond eating and drinking. A few of these places have appeared on other guides in this series. That's because they're good enough to recommend twice.