Most 'best gin bars' lists in this city are just the best cocktail bars with a gin garnish. Edinburgh actually earns a dedicated gin list: it has its own working distillery bar five minutes from Waverley, a Southside restaurant that's quietly won a dozen Scottish Gin Awards for the gin it makes in the room next door, and three more distilleries you can tour and taste at. Every venue here was checked against Google's live data and its own site, so these eight are all still open and still genuinely gin-led. A few well-known names, including one famous Edinburgh gin bar that's now permanently closed, didn't survive that check.
The scene splits cleanly by area. The Old Town has Edinburgh Gin's flagship at The Arches and McGonagalls' 100-plus-gin gantry on George IV Bridge. The West End has Heads & Tales, hidden down a stair beside The Huxley, and The Jolly Botanist's specialist gin menu on Morrison Street, both a short walk apart. Southside is where the actual distilling happens away from the tourist trail, at 56 North and at Summerhall, home of Pickering's Gin. And Leith has two proper craft distilleries, Lind & Lime on the waterfront and the smaller Shore Distillery. For a first-timer's tour, I'd book Edinburgh Gin. For the best gin actually made in the room you're drinking in, it's 56 North or Pickering's at Summerhall.
Two practical notes. Book ahead for any tour or tasting, none of these are reliable walk-ins at weekends, and Lind & Lime only opens Thursday to Sunday. And don't expect published prices at the bars themselves: only Lind & Lime and Shore Distillery quote exact tour prices online, so for the rest you're booking direct or turning up and asking. If you'd rather sort a full night out first, our things to do in Edinburgh guide is the place to start planning around it.